Controversy and confusion continue to surround Senate Bill 1342. Changes to the state’s eavesdropping law, which have recently sent to the governor for consideration, have been the subject of social media scrutiny with many people believing that it will make it illegal to record a police officer, regardless of the circumstances. The bill actually seeks to find a balance between protecting an individual’s privacy and ensuring public accountability of police and other public officials.
Under Senate Bill 1342, the public maintains the right to record police, because police have no reasonable expectation of privacy while working in a public place.
However, secretly recording private conversations would be illegal, protecting an individual’s right to privacy.
For years, Illinois’ privacy protections and eavesdropping prohibitions were some of the nation’s most strict. It was illegal to record anyone, in any context, without the consent of everyone involved. The same law protecting someone’s privacy could also send someone to prison for recording a police officer making an arrest.
In response, last spring the Supreme Court ruled portions of the law were unconstitutional. Thus the statute was negated, and all expectations of privacy with respect to eavesdropping or digital recording were stripped from the law. As a result, all conversations—public or private—could be recorded without fear of penalty.
Senate Bill 1342 was introduced to rectify this flaw. The measure seeks to balance two competing interests: the interest of one party to record and later disclose a conversation, and the right of the other party to keep the conversation from being recorded without their consent, if they can reasonably expect the conversation to have been considered private.
Citizens will be allowed to record the non-private conversations of others, such as a government official giving a speech in front of a group, a loud public argument, or conversations taking place on the street, public places and events, stadiums, public gatherings, etc.
It is not known whether Quinn will sign the measure. However, even if the Governor does sign the legislation, it will still be legal for people in Illinois to record communications with on-duty police officers, as long as they do not hinder the officers’ capacity to do his or her job.
As technology changes, this law and many others like it are a work in progress.